About the Insight Journal

Manifesto Technology Contribute

Our Vision

We envision a world where scientific research earns and maintains public trust through open, transparent, and reliable publishing platforms. The Insight Journal aims to repair and strengthen confidence in medical image analysis research by providing a publication venue that embraces full openness and reproducibility through Decentralized Science (DeSci).

Mission Statement

Enable reproducible scientific image analysis and visualization research by providing an open, interactive, and decentralized platform for publishing manuscripts, data, code, and research artifacts.

Our Values

The Insight Journal is built on three foundational pillars that align with the principles of Decentralized Science (DeSci):

🔓 Open Science

We champion complete openness in research dissemination and validation:

  • Open Access: No paywalls or publication charges. All research is freely available to everyone, everywhere, forever.
  • Reproducibility: All submissions include data, code, and parameters, enabling complete verification and reuse. Research that cannot be reproduced cannot be verified.
  • Transparency: Open peer-review with visible dialogues between reviewers and authors. The review process becomes part of the scientific record, increasing trust and accountability.
  • Innovation: Interactive, web-enabled visualizations and modern publishing tools (MyST, ITK-Wasm) transform passive reading into active exploration and enable computational reproducibility.

🌐 Decentralized Infrastructure

We build resilient, community-owned systems free from centralized control:

  • Distributed Storage: Content stored across the Interplanetary File System (IPFS) nodes ensures availability even if individual servers fail. Many copies keep things safe.
  • Verifiable Provenance: Cryptographic identifiers (DPIDs) and blockchain-based records create tamper-proof provenance for all contributions.
  • Community Governance: Decision-making power resides with the community, not corporate publishers. The journal's future belongs to its contributors.
  • Sustainability: Built on open-source principles with cost-effective infrastructure designed for long-term preservation and community ownership.

🤝 Community & Incentives

We recognize and reward all contributions to advance scientific progress:

  • Contributor Recognition: All contributors—authors, reviewers, data providers— receive formal credit through ORCID integration and attestations.
  • Reputation Systems: Quality contributions build verifiable reputation, creating incentives aligned with scientific progress that are recognized and rewarded through Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs).
  • Global Collaboration: Open participation regardless of institutional affiliation, geography, or career stage. Merit is measured by contribution, not credentials.
  • Fairness & Equity: Equal access to publication and review opportunities, removing barriers that exclude researchers from underrepresented communities.

The Problem with "Publish or Perish"

The current publishing system has inverted priorities. The motto "Publish or Perish" reveals its corruption—note that it does not say "Research or Perish!" This subtle distinction has profound consequences: researchers work "in order to publish" rather than because their work has significant impact on society.

This system forces researchers to embark only on publishable activities, which discourages significant departures from views held by the establishment of experts who serve as journal reviewers. Innovation is stifled; conformity is rewarded.

Publications are counted for career advancement, not evaluated for quality, relevance, or impact. The number of publications in your CV—not their substance—matters when seeking:

  • A degree
  • A job in industry or academia
  • A tenure position in a university
  • A promotion
  • A grant from federal or state agencies

The Scientific Method

The Scientific Method was introduced by Galileo in the 1500s when he embarked on a series of attempts to answer fundamental questions about physics by performing experiments. Galileo was also at the center of the first scientific journal, published by the "Linceans," also known as the Society of the Lynx. The name derived from the acute vision of this animal, conveying the idea that careful observation of experiments was required for finding truth about scientific matters.

Portrait of Galileo Galilei by Justus Sustermans
Portrait of Galileo Galilei by Justus Sustermans

The Insight Journal returns to these principles: careful observation, reproducible experiments, and open sharing of methods and results. We seek to support the altruistic motivation of performing scientific research rather than the corrupted imperative to publish for career advancement.

Our Strategy

To establish the Insight Journal as the premier publication venue in scientific and medical image analysis, we aim to:

  • Set global standards for openness and interactive scholarship
  • Drive progress toward a truly FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) and transparent research ecosystem
  • Build robust community governance
  • Catalyze scientific collaboration and nurture innovation
  • Transform passive reading into active engagement through interactive visualizations